The Love For Lost Continues


by Emily Offshack (@CanadianEmily)

It has been over two years since Lost ended. The controversial finale caused as many different fan reactions as there were DHARMA branded food products.

SPOILERS BELOW (Really? You haven’t seen it?)

I loved the ending. In the moment, there was a temporary panic that the last shot was going to be inside a church in a “place” that was different from what we watched for six years. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed the flash-sideways story as a new way to experience the journey, but the perfect ending had to come full circle with the beginning. It did, and it was satisfying. After it was over, part of my identity seemed to vanish. There were tears.

If you were one of the viewers who were upset or simply dissatisfied with the ending, here are some things to think about, two years later, when the Lost hormones have settled down a bit:

We never wanted all the answers.

True, there were a few plot points that would have been nice to see expanded, but in terms of the mythological aspects of the show, answers may have been worse than ambiguity. Walt has special powers because…while his mom was pregnant, Jacob sprinkled some of his completely normal wine on her belly. The heart of the island could turn the Man in Black into the Smoke Monster because… it was inhabited by 23 magical aliens who were the first living beings on the island. Maybe you can think of explanations that involve electromagnetism and other scientific principles that most of us don’t understand, but it was more likely going to be the-voices-are-dead-people-stuck-on-the-island type answers. We got a lot of answers. The remaining supernatural elements can remain just that: supernatural.

There is plenty of new story potential.

I know, we don’t want a new Lost. Two years ago, I couldn’t tolerate any mention of a new reiteration of my favorite show. Now, my feelings are beginning to change. Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse have said they would not be involved in a new Lost project, but that ABC retains the rights to the show. Think of a prequel, or a story about the future of Hurley, Ben and Walt. Maybe it’s not a TV show or movie. Maybe it’s another video game or a comic book. There is great material in the Lost universe, and in the hands of talented, die-hard fans, it could be amazing.

The fact that the ending upset many people still says something great about the show.

Viewers were so invested in Lost that they started to get nervous about the ending years before the finale. If you are one of the fans who stuck with the show but hated the ending, try to enjoy the parts you loved and continue making up theories for the parts that you didn’t. I still have a completely workable theory that Jughead did indeed contribute to the creation of the flash-sideways universe, despite many confirmations to the contrary. You can now proceed to roll your eyes and yell at me.

The fans remain awesome.

Every time that I am fortunate enough to get together with a group of Lost fans, it is fantastic. They can still discuss theories for hours. Really, it’s a gift that we still have unanswered mysteries to talk about, because the experience of Lost was just as much about the discussion and community as it was the show. At Comic Con this year, Lost fans continued to gather at Jay and Jack’s panel. At Nerd HQ, Damon Lindelof held a sold-out panel as part of Conversations for a Cause. He was kind enough to sign autographs and chat with the fans after; I will speak on behalf of everyone there and say that it was an incredible experience for all of us Losties in attendance.

Lost fans are charitable, too. From August 15-29, 2012, Jo Garfein and Jared Wong hosted a charity auction, Cancer Gets Lost, with 100% of the proceeds benefiting the National Brain Tumor Society. The auction consisted of many Lost-related memorabilia, props and autographed items. On August 25, in conjunction with the auction, a live webcast was hosted with members of the Lost cast and creative team.

When the tenth anniversary of the Lost finale rolls around, I fully expect there to be as much craze as there was for this year’s Firefly anniversary. Passionate nerds are awesome.



  1. RM PeavySeptember 4th, 2012 at 9:15 pm

    I heard a podcast with Damon Lindelof, but as a Lost fan you probably already heard this, that Jack and Locke are very parallel to what Damon Lindelof was feeling at the time when he became the showrunner for the show, and he had recently lost his dad, who was an atheist, It was really interesting to see how that had developed into those two characters. If you get a chance and you havent yet, It’s the nerdist writers panel, with Jane Espenson and Damon Lindelof and a few more people.

  2. RM PeavySeptember 4th, 2012 at 9:17 pm

    I also loved the ending. I noticed the people who didn’t like the ending hadnt seen the show in it’s entirety, to them I say poo.

  3. MarcusSeptember 4th, 2012 at 11:44 pm

    I saw the show in its entirety, and I still hated the ending. I hated it to the point where the first words out of my mouth were I wasted 6 years of my life. Some people dug it and I am glad they liked, but for me the ending tainted the whole show. It has taken all the two years since the show ended for me to even attempt find any joy in the show. The only way I can even begin to enjoy the show again is looking at it as character piece, other than that to me show is just jumbled piece of bad story telling. I am talking about the show as whole not episodes when I talk about bad story telling.

  4. BeccaSeptember 5th, 2012 at 9:28 am

    I get choked up every damned time I talk about the ending. It was fabulous.
    And I will argue with anyone who gives me the ridiculous “they were in purgatory” or “they were dead the whole time” crap.

    Actually, one of my biggest issues with Nerd HQ this year is that they didn’t make it clear that I could leave for an autograph and still get into the next conversation. I asked two HQ volunteers if I’d have time to go out but I was told by both that I should stay put for Grimm … there was not enough time for me to leave and get my autograph. Turns out, there was more than enough time AND they let Grimm ticket holders go first. Honestly, the fact that I missed talking with one of my idols gets me almost as choked up as the last episode did! I still carry quite a bit of resentment toward HQ for that. 😐

  5. MarcusSeptember 9th, 2012 at 2:26 am

    Becca I think everyone feels your pain when it comes to the HQ, hopefully it will be better organized this year.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Sorry. No data so far.



Read More